inclusive workplace

Gendered dress code: collaboration with cliniX

Can employers legally mandate different clothing based on gender in the workplace?

Mise à jour de l'auteur

Behind this seemingly simple question lies a complex legal reality. To find a clear answer, Fondation Émergence collaborated with the UQAM Social Justice Clinic (cliniX) to produce a legal opinion and a plain-language guide, now available for free in our download store.

Gendered dress codes: definition and issues

"A dress code is a rule that dictates how a person must dress or present themselves in a specific setting, such as at school, at work, or in an institution. This can include clothing, as well as hair, makeup, tattoos, etc. A dress code is gendered when it sets out different rules for men and women." (excerpt from Gendered dress codes: what does the law say? )  

The problem? These dress codes are often based on gender stereotypes (e.g., men must wear pants and women must wear skirts) and can limit self-expression for everyone. Furthermore, this can create challenges for trans and non-binary individuals.  

The result: these policies can lead to exclusion, discomfort, and discrimination in the workplace.

Gendered dress codes: a gray area?

Given that gender identity and gender expression are protected grounds against discrimination, it seemed obvious to us that it should not be permissible to impose different dress codes on people based on their gender identity. However, our initial research yielded only vague or even contradictory answers. We even found an article in a Quebec journal stating that "it is possible and legal for a dress code policy to be different for women than for men" and that "a company could ask waitresses to wear a skirt rather than pants." How can organizations respect their employees' rights if they aren't clear? And how can LGBTQ+ individuals enforce their rights when they don't know what they are?  

To clear up this mystery, we needed the insight and legal expertise of cliniX.  

Collaboration with the cliniX legal clinic  

cliniX is the social justice clinic for gender and sexuality issues at the Université du Québec à Montréal (UQAM). In practical terms, it is a course offered by the UQAM Department of Legal Sciences in which students enrolled in the bachelor’s program, the master’s in law, and the certificate in social work and labor studies get involved in real rights advocacy cases concerning gender and sexuality. Four projects are carried out each semester, stemming directly from partner community organizations, with the goal of meeting their concrete needs. The student team, supervised by lawyers and professors specializing in various fields of law, works with a community organization to provide them with answers.  

First, the cliniX team analyzed current laws, case law, and the principles of human rights and labor law to produce a legal opinion. Then, in a second phase, a Q&A tool was created to make these findings more accessible.  

View the tool

Gendered dress codes: legal or discriminatory?  

We invite you to consult the full tool to better understand the nuances and logic behind this position, but here is an excerpt:  

“ a gendered dress code is likely discriminatory. (…) Yes, an employer can set rules about clothing, but only if those rules are fair, necessary, and non-discriminatory. Gendered dress codes are therefore very unlikely to be legal. The best way to protect both employers and employees is to have a gender-neutral dress code, where everyone can choose what they are comfortable wearing, regardless of their gender.”

By clarifying the legal obligations surrounding gendered dress codes in Quebec, this project helps foster inclusive and respectful environments and enables LGBTQ+ individuals, as well as those who do not conform to gender stereotypes (e.g., masculine women, men who want to wear their hair long, etc.), to have their rights upheld.  

Quelques articles similaires

inclusive workplace

Gendered dress code: collaboration with cliniX

Can employers legally mandate different clothing based on gender in the workplace?

senior symposium

Fondation Émergence announces its symposium: "The Realities of LGBTQ+ Seniors: Where Do We Stand?"

Fondation Émergence will host the first symposium in Quebec dedicated to the realities of LGBTQ+ seniors. This day of reflection will bring together researchers, practitioners, and organizations to assess the current situation, share existing knowledge, and identify concrete paths for action to create more inclusive and safe living environments.

thérapie

Pour un monde sans thérapie de conversion : un projet franco-québécois pour sensibiliser et former les organisations internationales

La Fondation Émergence est fière d’annoncer un partenariat avec SOS Homophobie (France) dans le cadre du projet « Pour un monde sans thérapie de conversion », soutenu par la Commission permanente de coopération franco-québécoise (CPCFQ).